Menu
keyboard_backspace
ask a question ask a question
Get Realtime Updates of your Request. Download Vidhkarya App

Ask a Question - Free Legal Advice

Q.corporation asking to pay commercial property tax
Administrative Law (422)
Adoption (118)
Advertising (45)
Animal Laws (38)
Arbitration and Mediation (38)
Aviation (15)
Banking (518)
Bankruptcy and Debt (171)
Cheque Bounce (379)
Child Custody (147)
Civil (1945)
Commercial (68)
Consumer Protection (548)
Contracts and Agreements (452)
Corporate and Incorporation (91)
Criminal (1517)
Customs, Excise (34)
Cyber, Internet, Information Technology (320)
Debt and Lending Agreement (76)
Debt Collection (142)
Divorce (472)
Divorce and Separation (1599)
Documentation (298)
Domestic Violence (546)
Election Campaign and Political Laws (20)
Employment and Labour (1046)
Environment and Natural Resources (29)
Family (1851)
Financial Markets and Services (89)
Government Contracts (51)
Human Rights (255)
Immigration (54)
Industrial Laws (51)
Insurance (67)
Intellectual Property, Copyright, Patent, Trademark (98)
International Laws (11)
IT Contracts (41)
Juvenile (17)
Landlord and Tenant (576)
Licensing (21)
Mail Fraud (14)
Maternity (57)
Media, Communication, Entertainment (16)
Mergers and Acquisition (20)
Military Laws (9)
Motor Accident (132)
Muslim Laws (56)
Outsourcing Agreement/Laws (5)
Partnership (58)
Police Laws (60)
Power of Attorney (74)
Privacy (89)
Property (2738)
Real Estate (402)
Registration (134)
RTI (110)
Sale (57)
Sale of Goods (20)
Sex Crime (136)
Sexual Harassment (6)
Sexual Harassment at Workplace (69)
Software License (4)
Tax (13)
Tax-GST (6)
Tax-Income Tax (22)
Tax-Property Tax (30)
Telecommunication (10)
Torts (16)
Transportation (49)
Trust and Society (NGO) (80)
Will (142)
Work Permits (30)

Q. corporation asking to pay commercial property tax

Sir,
I'm having 18-rooms building in pune. It is individually owned. Recently 1-year before maintenance society was formed and it made complaint against me to Pune Muncipal Corporation to charge me as commercial property tax. Till now since last 20-years I've been paying residential tax. In 12-rooms i'm keeping paying guest. Is it correct for the Muncipal Corporation to charge me as Commercial tax ? What I've to do so that corporation does not charge my property as commercial because Paying guest is not an commercial business?
Share this questionShare Icon

Showing 7 of 7 Responses

A. Making any sort of earnings or profit from house property either from paying guest or tenants amounts to commercial business and the Corporation is correct in putting your property under commercial cap. What you can do is to appear before the concerned hearing officer on the date of hearing as mentioned in the notice and seek for some relief in the property tax.

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon

ROBERT D ROZARIO

Experience: 15 Year(s)

Responded 8 months ago

View All Answers
View {{count[0]}} Replies
Placeholder image

sachin Yewale

Experience: 1 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

yes. The corncerned hearing officer for the time being has given relief for the time being. But he said the society complaint about you so we took further action. I told him commercial tax has to be levied on other neighbouring properties or flats also who have given on leave license to families or bachelors. You cannot just point out me alone for the commercial tax on behalf of society complaint. It's not justified.

Placeholder image

ROBERT D ROZARIO

Experience: 15 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

Merely putting up your submission before the Hearing officer will do no good. You need to give a written representation to the municipality and thereafter file a writ petition in Bombay High Court and bring all those neighbours to accountability. This is a teeth for tat tactics. Why only you suffer will others levied with a residential property tax. If you want you can engage me to conduct your case in Bombay High Court.

Placeholder image

ROBERT D ROZARIO

Experience: 15 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

If you are aggrieved by the order of the hearing officer, you can prefer an appeal before the Pune Municipal Tribunal. There's a limitation period to prefer such appeal. So do what is appropriate.

Placeholder image

sachin Yewale

Experience: 1 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

Thanks a lot for your valuable suggestion. Hearing officer is not giving information on current tax rate i.e. per sq ft rate for residential and commercial property. Exact formula to calculate tax is also not clear. In other states tax rate for residential, commercial, Hostel, Hotel or lodging is different. But Pune Municipal is not transparent in its policy?
It's not even mentioned on PMC website!!!
When to start legal proceedings after we receive property tax bill or we have to ask hearing officer to give in written their demands for the tax amount they want to charge?
How much would be High court fees or legal expenses to file writ petition as you mentioned above??
Ultimately after doing all this will my property be charged with commercial or residential tax or some other solution?

Reply

A. Kindly contact VIDHIKARYA for further discussion.

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon

Namitabh Kothari

Experience: 19 Year(s)

Responded 8 months ago

View All Answers
Reply Here

A. Dear Sir,
You can go to High Court and get stay order if any issued Municipal Corporation. However you can ignore the notice issued by the society.

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon
Reply Here

A. represent your case to M.C. through some advocate. Contact vidhikarya.com in the matter

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon

Rajender Prasad

Experience: 5 Year(s)

Responded 8 months ago

View All Answers
Reply Here

A. Dear client kindly file case for change your tax profile into commercial tax

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon

Deepak Bade

Experience: 9 Year(s)

Responded 8 months ago

View All Answers
View {{count[4]}} Reply
Placeholder image

sachin Yewale

Experience: 1 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

currently my tax profile is residential i do not want to change to commercial tax. If a flat is give on rent does it attracts commercial tax? Same way it's my residence i've extra rooms so i keep paying guest how can i pay commercial tax?

Reply

A. You will have to challenge the commercial tax by filing case in court

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon

Namitabh Kothari

Experience: 19 Year(s)

Responded 8 months ago

View All Answers
View {{count[5]}} Replies
Placeholder image

sachin Yewale

Experience: 1 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

what would be our stand for filing case in court? can u elaborate

Placeholder image

Namitabh Kothari

Experience: 19 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

Kindly contact VIDHIKARYA for further discussion.

Reply

A. By advocate Rameshwor dadhe dear sir you are using it as a commercial purposes. You must pay taxes like commercial. Commercial tax attract on his property. Municipal corporation are on right way

Found Helpful
Found Helpful
Share this answerShare Icon

Rameshwar Dadhe

Experience: 2 Year(s)

Responded 8 months ago

View All Answers
View {{count[6]}} Replies
Placeholder image

sachin Yewale

Experience: 1 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

It's my residence and in extra rooms i'm keeping paying guest how can it be commercial? It's not shop or office only students or bachelors stay as per their requirement. If a flat given on rent to students or family also attracts commercial property tax? A lot of flats given on rent in my area but they do not pay commercial tax? How does this commercial tax applies to me only instead of all other rented premises also?

Placeholder image

Rameshwar Dadhe

Experience: 2 Year(s)

Replied 8 months ago

Dear sir residential is deferent and paying guest. Is coming in the commercial purposes. It is your income source.

Reply
Talk to a Lawyer
Post Your Matter
Request Callback
Contact Us