A.
Based on the facts stated, your mother appears to have a reasonably strong case for seeking eviction of the daughter-in-law under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, particularly if she is the sole and absolute owner of the Mumbai property, the property is her self-acquired property, and the daughter-in-law has no ownership interest in it. Recent decisions of the Bombay High Court and the Supreme Court of India have repeatedly recognized that tribunals under the Senior Citizens Act may direct eviction of children or relatives, including daughters-in-law, where such occupation interferes with the senior citizen's right to live peacefully, safely, and with dignity in their own property. Courts have emphasized that the Act is a welfare legislation intended to protect elderly persons from harassment and deprivation of their property rights.
However, the daughter-in-law's potential claim under Section 17 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 cannot be ignored. The leading Supreme Court decision in S. Vanitha held that eviction proceedings under the Senior Citizens Act should not automatically override a woman's right to reside in a "shared household" under the DV Act. Instead, the competing rights of the senior citizen and the daughter-in-law must be balanced. A tribunal or court is expected to examine whether the property genuinely qualifies as a shared household, whether any residence order already exists in the daughter-in-law's favour, whether alternative accommodation is available, and whether the senior citizen's need for protection outweighs the residence claim.
In your mother's case, several facts strengthen her position. The son and daughter-in-law allegedly shifted to a separate rented residence in 2016 because of disputes and remained away for approximately nine years, returning only after the son's death in October 2025. That long period of separate residence may help rebut an argument that the property remained the daughter-in-law's continuing matrimonial home or shared household. Further, if no residence order under the DV Act presently exists and the daughter-in-law has independent financial support through approximately ₹22 lakh in death benefits and a continuing family pension, a tribunal may view her claim for continued occupation more narrowly. The mother's advanced age, medical vulnerability (single kidney), limited pension income, and allegations of ongoing harassment are all factors that tend to support relief under the Senior Citizens Act. Courts have recently upheld eviction where senior citizens established harassment, loss of peaceful enjoyment of their property, and lack of any ownership rights in favour of the daughter-in-law.
That said, litigation outcomes are highly fact-sensitive. If the daughter-in-law can establish that the property was the matrimonial home for a substantial period, that she has no realistic alternative accommodation, or that proceedings under the DV Act are already pending with residence-related relief sought, the tribunal may be required to fashion a balanced remedy rather than grant immediate eviction. Some courts have directed alternative accommodation arrangements or considered residence rights before ordering removal.
Overall, assuming the property is solely owned by the mother, there is no existing court order granting the daughter-in-law residence rights, and credible evidence of harassment can be produced, the mother's prospects of obtaining an eviction order under the Senior Citizens Act appear better than average. The strongest evidence would include title documents, proof that the son and daughter-in-law lived separately since 2016, medical records demonstrating the mother's health condition, police complaints or other evidence of harassment, and documents showing the daughter-in-law's independent financial resources.
Posted On 11-Jun-2026
Share on
×