Why Judges Break The Nib of Their Pen After Passing a Death Sentence ?


Posted On : September 24, 2019
This blog throws light on the symbolic breaking of the nib of the pen by the judges and why it's customary when a death sentence in India is decreed.
Listen to this article

Table of Contents

Ever since the British Raj, it's customary for Indian judges to snap the nib after a death sentence has been proclaimed. However, it's doubtful as to how many people are aware of the purpose of or reason behind the custom. There are several reasons for a judge resorting to such action after passing the judgment.


Why this practice is in effect in courtrooms?

There is symbolism in the breaking of the nib of a pen and the message conveyed through this symbolic act is that the pen that was used to decree capital punishment would never be used to decree similar punishment ever again.   


Fundamentally, a death sentence in India is an extreme action taken as a response to radical anti-social activities that are unresolvable otherwise.  


The symbolism of a broken nib of a pen is that the pen is tainted by the judge decreeing that a person be thrown to the gallows so to speak intends to get rid of it by snapping the nib.

Judges probably snap the nib of a pen that they use to sign a person’s life away so as to distance himself/herself from the guilt feeling of decreeing capital punishment.

Judges can neither review nor revoke once the judgment is in writing and has been signed. Hence, the nib is snapped to prevent the judge from having any second thoughts about his/her own judgment. 


It's sad to throw someone to the gallows or take someone’s life also known as capital punishment, but it's necessary occasionally and snapping the nib of the pen used to decree the death sentence is an expression of grief. A death sentence is a capital punishment that breaks the heart of a judge signing someone’s life away. Hence the symbolic snapping of the nib of the pen used by the judge to proclaim the death sentence as an expression of sorrow and guilt feeling.


Click here to connect to Vidhikarya’s registered expert criminal lawyers for further legal advice in this regard. 

Written By:
Avik  Chakravorty

Avik Chakravorty


Recommended Free Legal Advices
question markspouse issue 2 Response(s)
Hi, Since this is a false case of 498A, you can file a suit for defamation and mental cruelty on all the grounds you mentioned above. It can also be taken as a ground for divorce if you desire to seek so. If you like my answer, please give a good review.
question markFailure in execution of Bailable Warrants BWs, inefficient judges & clerks 2 Response(s)
Hi client, If you are not satisfied with any particular order or judgement, you can challenge the same to the higher authority. Thanks and Regards Simi Paul
question markCan I Install and do Pen Culture in my FTL 50 acres agriculture land 2 Response(s)
Dear Client Here I see two issues because of which you may not be able to go ahead with your plan they are; 1. Losses to the income of the other people which might be there due to your business and inconvenience caused to them. 2. Getting the approval from the Fishery department to start the culture. If you are able to navigate from these two issues then you can I think
question markStamp paper is valid or not if we use ball pen 2 Response(s)
Dear Client, No it can’t be used in stamp paper but new one in place of wrong stamp paper. You may go to the electronic type writer and get it corrected the correct way .
question markStreet Dogs 1 Response(s)
Dear Client, If you are facing issues with judges or any other individuals in your neighborhood regarding your efforts to feed street dogs, it's important to find an amicable solution while respecting local laws and regulations. Here are some steps you can consider taking: Engage in Open Communication: Try to initiate a respectful and open dialogue with the judges or their representatives. Explain your intentions and the importance of feeding and caring for street dogs. Listen to their concerns and address any misconceptions they may have about your activities. Contact Local Authorities: Reach out to your local municipal or animal control authorities to inquire about any specific regulations or guidelines regarding feeding street dogs. Ensure that you are in compliance with any local laws related to animal welfare and feeding stray animals. Educate and Raise Awareness: Create awareness among your neighbors and community members about the importance of caring for street dogs and responsible animal welfare. Organize community meetings or awareness campaigns to address concerns and provide information on proper ways to care for stray animals. Collaborate with Animal Welfare Organizations: Seek support and guidance from local animal welfare organizations or NGOs that may have experience in managing street dog populations. These organizations can provide advice on humane methods of caring for stray animals and may even assist with vaccination and sterilization programs. Consider Legal Recourse: If your efforts to communicate and cooperate with the judges do not yield positive results, consult with a legal expert to understand your rights and options under the law. Legal action should be a last resort and should be pursued only if all other avenues have been exhausted. Remember that while caring for street dogs is a compassionate act, it should be done in a way that is respectful of local laws and the concerns of your neighbors. Finding a balance that allows you to continue your humane efforts while addressing any issues with neighbors or local authorities is essential. Thank you.