Mandatory CSR Spending in India: Applicability, Rules and Penalties for Non-Compliance

Mandatory CSR spending in India has moved from “good corporate behaviour” to a clear board-level legal duty. So, CSR is not only about donating money when profits look healthy. Now, it sits inside -

• Governance
• Accounts
• Disclosures
• Project monitoring
• Regulatory risk. 

For companies that cross the statutory thresholds, CSR compliance in India becomes an annual obligation. It is no longer a one-time philanthropic exercise.

Understanding the Legal Basis of Mandatory CSR Spending

Primarily, Corporate Social Responsibility in India flows from Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013. It must be read with the Companies (Corporate Social Responsibility Policy) Rules, 2014. 

In simple terms, the law expects profitable or large companies to allocate part of their profits to socially recognised activities. However, the provision is not a form of loose charity. Rather, it has -

• Conditions
• Timelines
• Reporting duties
• Consequences.

The broad idea is sensible enough. For instance, a company might use public infrastructure, labour markets, natural resources, and local ecosystems. Therefore, once it reaches a certain size or profit level, the law asks it to contribute back in an organised manner. 

At this point, experienced corporation lawyers add real value. This is because they help companies treat CSR as governance planning.

Under the Companies Act, CSR rests with the board. The CSR Committee may recommend policies, expenditures, and projects. But the board cannot simply sit back and say the committee handled it. 

Moreover, the board must ensure that CSR activities align with Schedule VII. It must also ensure that the company properly reports all information in its annual disclosures.

The CSR rules in India also make one thing clear. CSR is not -

• A marketing campaign
• An employee benefit scheme
• A political contribution
• A routine business expense dressed up in social language. 

Instead, CSR must fall within the recognised areas. These include -

1. Education
2. Health
3. Sanitation
4. Environment
5. Rural development
6. Gender equality
7. Disaster management
8. Heritage protection
9. Similar public-interest activities.

Legal Points and Their Meaning

Legal Point

Practical Meaning

Section 135 applicability

Applies when a company crosses specified financial thresholds

CSR spend

At least 2% of the average net profits of the preceding three financial years

Board responsibility

Board approves, monitors, and reports CSR obligations

Schedule VII

CSR activity must fit within permitted areas

Non-compliance

Penalties may apply for failure to spend, transfer, or disclose properly

Is CSR mandatory for every company in India?

CSR is not mandatory for every company. Instead, it applies only when a company crosses any statutory threshold for -

• Net worth
• Turnover
• Net profit. 

Therefore, a small private company may voluntarily spend on social causes. However, Section 135 obligations arise only after the legal trigger is met.

Shall a company count normal business expenses as CSR?

Regular business expenses cannot become CSR merely because they have some social benefit. For example, the following usually do not qualify:

• Employee welfare
• Brand promotion
• Activities done in the ordinary course of business. 

Basically, the activity must fit the legal framework and serve a recognised public purpose.

Applicability of the CSR Law in India: Who Has to Comply?

During the immediately preceding financial year, a company might have -

• A net worth of ₹500 crore or more
• Turnover of ₹1,000 crore or more
• Net profit of ₹5 crore or more.

Then, a company must comply with the CSR law in India. In this case, a company need not meet all three conditions.

For instance, mid-sized businesses may not look like large conglomerates. Still, a strong year of profits might pull them into the CSR framework. 

Consequently, CSR compliance in India is not only a concern for listed companies or big industrial houses. The following businesses may also fall within the net:

• Private companies
• Subsidiaries
• Closely held businesses.

Once the CSR provisions apply, the company must calculate 2% of the average net profit of the immediately preceding three financial years. If the company has not completed three financial years since incorporation, the calculation applies to the immediately preceding financial years available. 

There is also a relaxation regarding the formation of the CSR Committee. If the CSR amount does not exceed ₹50 lakh, the board may discharge the functions of the CSR Committee. Still, this does not eliminate the obligation to spend, track, or report. 

Does CSR apply if only net profit crosses ₹5 crore?

Obviously, CSR applies even if only the net profit threshold is crossed. In fact, a company might not have a net worth of ₹500 crore or a turnover of ₹1,000 crore. 

Therefore, a profitable company with moderate turnover may still be eligible for the CSR framework. It happens if its net profit reaches the prescribed level.

Is CSR calculated on the current year's profit?

At the outset, the CSR spending requirement is generally linked to 2% of the average net profits of the preceding three financial years.

So, the company must look backwards for the calculation. It is important, even though the spending obligation applies to the relevant financial year. This prevents calculation errors.

Spending, Transfer, and Reporting Duties Under CSR Rules in India

Primarily, the law expects the company to spend the required CSR amount on eligible activities. However, the company may not be able to spend the full amount. Then, the next step depends on whether the unspent amount relates to an ongoing project. 

Sometimes, the unspent amount does not relate to an ongoing project. Then the company must transfer it to a fund specified in Schedule VII. It must happen within six months of the end of the financial year. 

However, if the unspent amount relates to an ongoing project, the company must transfer it to a separate Unspent CSR Account. This must happen within thirty days of the end of the financial year.

After that, the company typically has three financial years to spend the amount (held in the Unspent CSR Account) on the ongoing project. If it remains unspent after that period, the amount must be transferred to a specified Schedule VII fund. 

Moreover, the board report must disclose CSR details. These include:

1. Composition of the CSR Committee
2. Policy
3. Amount required to be spent
4. Amount actually spent
5. Reasons for shortfall
6. Treatment of unspent amounts. 

Furthermore, companies must also comply with prescribed CSR reporting formats and filings. 

Rules to Follow

This is what you must do for CSR reporting:

1. Prepare the CSR plan before the last quarter. Do not wait until the accounts team starts chasing deadlines.
2. Check Schedule VII fit before approving the project.
3. Maintain board minutes and project agreements. Also, check utilisation records and impact documents.
4. Track ongoing projects separately from one-time CSR activities.
5. Match financial disclosures with statutory filings and board reporting.

What happens if CSR funds remain unspent because a project is still underway?

Sometimes the amount relates to a valid ongoing project. Then, the company should transfer the unspent amount to a separate Unspent CSR Account. It must happen within the prescribed time. 

After that, the company may then spend it within the allowed period. However, it must monitor the project and maintain proper records.

Is It Possible to Adjust Excess CSR Spending in Later Years?

It is possible to set off excess CSR spending against CSR obligations of succeeding financial years. However, it is subject to the prescribed conditions.

Meanwhile, the company should properly approve and document the excess spending. Otherwise, a later claim of set-off may create avoidable questions during scrutiny.

Penalties for Non-Compliance and Why Boards Should Not Treat CSR Lightly

Earlier, many companies treated CSR as a “comply or explain” matter. If they did not spend, they simply added reasons to the board report. Now, that approach is risky. This is because the law has become sharper. Moreover, regulators are reading financial statements, board reports, and filings together.

The key CSR penalty under Section 135 applies when the company fails to transfer unspent CSR amounts as required. The company may face a penalty of twice the unspent amount or ₹1 crore (whichever is lower). 

Also, officers in default may face penalties. In general, they are linked to one-tenth of the unspent amount or ₹2 lakh (whichever is lower).

That said, penalties are not only about the amount. Also, a CSR default signals weak internal governance. Moreover, it creates questions for executives and business partners. If the company repeatedly fails to meet CSR obligations, the issue appears structural.

Boards should therefore build a simple but serious CSR control system. 

1. Identify applicability early.
2. Calculate the obligation correctly.
3. Approve eligible projects with measurable outputs.
4. Monitor spending and keep documentary evidence ready.
5. Close the loop through clear reporting. 

The better view is that CSR should not become a forced donation exercise. Rather, it should align with -

• Community needs
• Long-term social outcomes
• Legal defensibility. 

Nevertheless, compliance must come first.

Do directors personally face consequences for CSR default?

Officers in default may face penalties where the law provides for such liability. Basically, directors should not assume CSR is merely an accounts department issue. 

Actually, the board carries statutory duties. So, directors must review -

• The applicability of CSR
• Spending status
• Unspent transfers
• Disclosures with due seriousness.

Is explaining non-spending enough to avoid a penalty?

Explaining non-spending is not always enough to avoid a penalty. Although a board explanation may still be necessary, it does not replace statutory transfer obligations. 

Sometimes the law requires the transfer of unspent amounts to an Unspent CSR Account or a Schedule VII fund. Then, a mere explanation in the report may not protect the company from consequences.

Mandatory CSR Is Now a Governance Duty

Mandatory CSR spending in India requires companies to link profit to responsibility. But it must happen in a legally structured way. 

In fact, the point is not to romanticise charity or punish business success. Rather, the law expects eligible companies to plan and spend. Also, they want them to monitor and transfer. Moreover, they must disclose with discipline.

For boards, the safer approach is to treat CSR as part of annual compliance planning. Also, check applicability even when the company is privately held or mid-sized. Further, keep the legal, finance, and project teams aligned before money moves out. 

In the end, CSR compliance in India works best when companies see it as governance with social purpose. It must not be mere paperwork with a donation receipt.

Share: