Menu
keyboard_backspace

Get Expert Advice Online
from Top Lawyers
in India

Read Blogs to get more Insights

A Rape Covered Under The Veil Of Marriage

A Rape Covered Under The Veil Of Marriage By Ashish Ranjan Samal, Advocate Orissa High Court 1. Introduction Whenever Mahira, who is 25 years old, has a fight or a heated argument with her husband, he takes it out on her in the bed. She is merely a toy for him whom he can use differently every night. He forces himself on her, every single day, even during her periods. Their relationship has never been about 'consent' and 'equality'. Similarly, many women are subjected to dowry harassment and brutal rape which involves inflictions with torch lights leading to serious injuries. These are just a few examples out of the plethora of such cases. These women are all married and they have to go through such kind of violence and forced intercourse. Is a wife merely a tool to vent out sexual and emotional tension and frustration? Marital rape is an oxymoron. Yet marriage and rape have an unfortunate continued relationship in India. Both rape and marriage are considered ways of gaining control over a woman's body since time immemorial. This was also exemplified in the infamous Imrana rape case[1] where back in 2005, 28-year-old Imrana, a mother of five, was raped by her 69-year-old father-in-law. And the Panchayat (local council) declared her marriage to her husband as void since she had had sex with her father-in-law and by virtue of her physical relationship with her father-in-law she was also told to treat her own husband as her son. The dictionary meaning of the word "rape" is "ravishing or violation of a woman" which in its generic term "Raptus" implies violent theft, applied to both property and person. Rape is the word for forced or coerced sex. It is when the woman has not had the opportunity to freely give consent or she is unable to give consent. Marital rape is the non-consensual sex committed by the spouse. It is also known as partner rape or rape in marriage. 2. Indirect laws addressing Marital Rape Marriage in India is considered a holy sacrament between a husband and his wife. When a man marries a woman, it not only brings implied consent of sexual intercourse but also the man's duty to give due respect to the dignity of his wife. When the husband commits unwanted forceful intercourse with his wife, he breaks the confidence of his wife and breaches her trust in him. Lately, Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code i.e. the anti-dowry law is voluminously misused by the women and a considerable number of rape cases reported each year are also false. Proving marital rape and taking bedrooms to courtrooms in such cases is not only a difficult but also a dangerous idea.[2] As per the Indian penal legislation i.e., Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code- "Sexual intercourse" or "sexual acts" by a man with his own wife, the wife not being under fifteen years of age, is not rape." [3] Exception to Section 375[4] of IPC provides immunity to the husband who rapes his wife and declares marital rape as legal and does not consider it as rape. This shows that the concept of marital rape goes beyond the virtues of Article 21[5] of the Constitution of India i.e. right to live with human dignity. Marital rape prima facie violates Article 14[6] of the Constitution as it creates a classification between married and unmarried women and denies equal protection of the criminal legislation to the former.[7] Though marital rape violates basic human rights that are attributed to every human being under the purview of these Articles there are not many remedies available to the victim. Therefore, in India, marital rape can come under cruelty clauses of section 498A of IPC. Cruelty covers physical and mental harassment. Punishment is imprisonment for a maximum period of three years with fine. The remedies for cruelty under the Indian Penal Code take years to reach an outcome. In view of this, victims remain victims. They either give in, or give up. Another remedy available to the wife is under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 which deals with protection of women from physical and mental cruelties of all forms, including sexual abuse. Family Courts as well as Magistrates provide counseling to the husband under domestic violence laws. But unfortunately, the provisions of this Act provide civil remedies only and a wife who wants to see her husband (rapist) punished finds no solution to that. Instead she is the one who struggles and suffers especially if she has children or is financially dependent or is without family support. The only lasting solution to the problem of marital rape is legal separation or annulment of the marriage itself. A legally separated wife can only file a complaint for rape against her husband under Section 376A[8] of IPC.[9] 3. Startling Statistics Marital rape is both common and an un-reported crime. A study conducted by the Joint Women Programme - an NGO, found that one out of seven married women had been raped by their husbands at least once. They frequently do not report these rapes because the law does not support them.[10] According to the UN Population Fund, more than two-thirds of married women in India, aged 15 to 49 years, have been beaten, or forced to provide sex.[11] Bertrand Russell in his book Marriage and Morals saw marriage as one of the most conventional forms of livelihood for a woman where the frequency of undesired intercourse she has to give in to is in all probabilities higher than that endured by a prostitute. [12] ?till the problem of marital rape has received very little attention from the activists, criminal justice system and the society at large. The concept of rape in marriage got recognition only after 1970s. The right of a husband to have sexual intercourse with his wife was considered to be one of the most natural implications of the contract of marriage.[13] International Instruments Article 2 of the Declaration of the Elimination of Violence against Women includes marital rape explicitly in the definition of violence against women.[14] Also the unanimous resolution at the UN conference in Beijing, September 1995 guarantees every woman the right to say no to sex as she wishes, specifically wives. In accordance with these Declarations and Conferences many countries have either enacted marital rape laws, repealed marital rape exceptions or have laws that do not distinguish between marital rape and ordinary rape. These States include Albania, Algeria, Australia (in 1991), Belgium, Canada, China, Denmark, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Mauritania, Mauritius (in 2007), New Zealand (under Crimes Act, 1961), Norway, the Philippines, Scotland, South Africa, Sweden, Taiwan, Tunisia, the United Kingdom (in 1991), the United States, and recently, Indonesia, Thailand (in 2007), Turkey (in 2005).[15] In England and Wales, the House of Lords held in 1991 that the status of married women had changed beyond all recognition. Lord Keith, compared a marriage of the modern times with a partnership of equals where the wife is no longer the subservient chattel of the husband.[16] 4. Rethinking of the existing law In India, the 42nd Law Commission Report (1972) suggested that marital rape should be criminalized. However, actions were not taken to that effect and the 84th Report (1980) was not in favour of the criminalization. In the year 1996 the Supreme Court of India in Bodhisattwa Gautam v. Subhra Chakraborty[17] classified rape as a crime against the basic human rights and a violation of the victim's most cherished of fundamental rights, namely, the right to life enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution. However, the Apex Court negated this very pronouncement by not recognizing marital rape.[18] This shows that the Indian courts as well as the law makers have made recommendations and pointed out the need for penalising marital rape several times. Still there has not been any substantial change in this field. 5. The gray areas There are a lot of loopholes in the Indian legal system when it comes to marital rape. It not only provides immunity to the rapist husband but is also silent with regard to a lot of questions. For example, there are no provisions to deal with the cases of rape which are committed by the husband in collusion with a third person or if rape is committed by both the husband and a third person. Whether the third person will only be punished for rape, or whether the husband, would escape punishment for marital rape owing to his relationship with the victim are some of the many questions which the law has failed to adequately answer.[19]  The honourable High Court of Delhi has rightly pointed out in the case of Meena & Anr. v. State & Anr.[20] on 17 October, 2012 where the Court observed that if a girl who is not the wife of the man but is below 16 years of age (15 as per the Criminal Law Amendment 2013) then even the consensual intercourse between the two amounts to rape. But if the girl is above 16 years and is wife of the man, then even the forced intercourse is not rape. This provision in the Indian Penal Code, 1860 is a specific illustration which shows that the legislature has legitimized the concept of child marriage by keeping a lower age of consent for marital intercourse. 6. The deep scars left from the crime Marital rape causes both mental as well as physical trauma which has severe and long-lasting consequences on women. The immediate physical and gynaecological effects of marital rape include injuries to private organs, lacerations, soreness, bruising, torn muscles, fatigue, vomiting, miscarriages, stillbirths, bladder infections. It may also lead to infertility and HIV. Rape in marriage has a lot of long-lasting psychological consequences also. It causes anxiety, shock, intense fear, depression, sleep problems, suicidal ideation, etc. [21] 7. Conclusion The concept of marital rape is an oxymoron. It is a rape under the veil of marriage. Marriage is not a licence for sex. Just because a woman says "I do" to marriage it does not mean that she has said "I do" to sex whenever, wherever, and however her husband wants it. Sex is not an implied 'right' under the contract of marriage rather it is a clear communication of love, mutual consent, caring and respect between husband and wife. A recent incident of gang rape and murder of a student on a bus in Delhi in 2012 led to a mass outcry. This outrage took place when the girl was raped by strangers. Had she been raped by her husband, would it have the same effect? If rape is the violation of human rights then it would continue to be a violation whether committed by her husband or a stranger. The dignity of women either married or unmarried is alike. She cannot be considered as a property or the subservient chattel of the husband In today's scenario we require generation of awareness along with judicial awakenings. What really needs to be done is to teach both boys and men to not rape and educate them to view women as valuable partners in every aspect of life.

Posted By

ASHISH SAMAL

1 week ago

Go to Blog

Who can claim Alimony Rights?

To put it bluntly, when women usually get divorce alimony legit claims are granted by the courts by default. Occasionally, the man may be able to prove that he had to undergo all sorts of harassment and the court on its part may decree that the female pay compensations. Conversely, the court’s decree could be that the husband reverts the ‘stree-dhan which essentially includes all assets that the woman had received when the man and the woman got married. All assets that the woman’s parents and in-laws gave her at the time of her marriage would have to be returned as well. For further read: What Do I Need to Know About Alimony before DivorceIs the claimant entitled to claim alimony rights? The alimony amount to be paid may vary and the court determines the amount on a case by case basis according to a divorce lawyer in IndiaFactors impacting alimony amount and duration are as follows:a) the duration of the wedding - if the couple’s marriage, for example, lasts for a decade the person entitled can claim maintenance for a lifetime b) age and health of the spouse – depending on the how well-off the payer is as well as whether the payer is the owner of properties c) the health condition of both spousesd) how the parties behave e) the spouse that gets child custody would be entitled to and therefore claim to either receive a higher amount for being the custodial parent of a minor child or the maintenance paid would be of a lesser amount f) Incurring the expenditure on account of raising the child g) the social status and the wife’s lifestyle as she and her husband lived together as married couples.h) any other aspect or circumstance of the case, that the court may consideri) husband’s any other legit liabilities, namely, fully dependent aging parents, that the courts have had evidence of by examining. If the wife has a job she would have an independent source of income which would be considered as well. Who can claim the alimony?Wife – In the case of the wife the possibilities are limited to three and they are as follows:a) if she is earning – if the man has a higher earning potential and comes from a decent financial background then she has entitlement and therefore can claim alimony.b) if she is not earning – in such a scenario, the man ought to ensure that the standard of living of the woman remains the same as it was during her married life c) if she remarries – remarriage of the woman would result in the man paying for the children only and the woman is exempted or excluded from alimony payments. The Hindu marriage act, 1955 and section 25 of the act, in particular, is the guideline or the guiding light for those who are under the ambit of the act. Section 25 of the act is appropriately applied with the granting of the final divorce decree. However, applying for this express purpose even after the granting of the divorce, the court will consider the application and alimony would be granted. Besides, all individual alimony claims can be canceled by the court if it's found later on that the person claiming alimony has remarried, or has had an extramarital affair.For further consultation, Vidhikarya can connect you with experienced lawyers.

Posted By

Avik Chakravorty

1 week ago

Go to Blog

{{ item.userName }}

{{ item.review }}

{{ item.createdOn }}

Hetvi Sancheti

(See Reviews)

Experience

: {{lawyerExperience}}

Designation

: Litigation Attorney

Practicing Court

: Gujarat High Court

Location

: Gujarat, Ahmedabad

State Bar Council

: Gujarat

Reviews & Ratings(View Reviews)

We specialize in Corporate and commercial Litigation, Insolvency, Corporate frauds, Insolvency disputes, Arbitration disputes, cheque bounce cases and related litigation and operating in legal advisory market for over 13 years. We represent clients in NCLT, Gujarat High Court, Arbitral Tribunals.

Professional Summary

  • Corporate: - Mismanagement and oppression, Insolvency, Corporate frauds related litigation in NCLT and Gujarat High Court.
  • Criminal: Special Laws like Negotiable Instruments (Dishonor of cheques), Food Adulteration, Corruption, Narcotics, offences under Penal Code, etc related litigation in Gujarat High Court, Sessions Court and other District Courts situated in Ahmedabad.
  • Civil: Works Contract (Public Works Department) related Arbitration and other litigation, Revenue matters, T.P Schemes, SEZ, Land Acquisition, Writs related litigation of AUDA, AMC,
  • Consumer Disputes, Unfair Trade Practices in State Consumer Commission


Expertise In

Primary Expertise

Category Experience(in years) Cases Remarks
Bankruptcy and Debt 13 years 150 Cases falling under IBC handled in NCLT, Ahmedabad
Cheque Bounce 13 years 400 Extensively conducted Trials of cheque bounce cases, filed quashing matters in Gujarat High Court
Commercial 13 years 200 Commercial Litigation in Gujarat High Court.
Criminal 13 years 400 ? Litigated extensively in Criminal cases including cases falling under special laws like Narcotics,... Read More
Arbitration and Mediation 13 years 300 Expertise in enforcement of Foreign Arbitration Awards, Construction Contracts , Stock Exchange, Shi... Read More

Secondary Expertise

Expertise In

Bankruptcy and Debt

Experience 13 years

Number of Cases 150

Cases falling under IBC handled in NCLT, Ahmedabad

Cheque Bounce

Experience 13 years

Number of Cases 400

Extensively conducted Trials of cheque bounce cases, filed quashing matters in Gujarat High Court

Commercial

Experience 13 years

Number of Cases 200

Commercial Litigation in Gujarat High Court.

Criminal

Experience 13 years

Number of Cases 400

? Litigated extensively in Criminal cases including cases falling under special laws like Narcotics, Corruption, Negotiable Instruments, Food Adulteration in Gujarat High Court as well as Trial Courts (Sessions Court, CBI Special Court, and Ahmedabad Rural). The nature of matters dealt with includes Criminal Appeals, Bail, Revision, Quashing, and Writ Petitions

Arbitration and Mediation

Experience 13 years

Number of Cases 300

Expertise in enforcement of Foreign Arbitration Awards, Construction Contracts , Stock Exchange, Shipping services, Media related Arbitration

Other Areas of Expertise

Practicing Court Name

Gujarat High Court

High Court

Ahmedabad City Civil and Sessions Court

Sessions Court

NCLT Ahmedabad

Tribunal

International Arbitration Tribunal and other Arbitrations

Others

Educations

LL.M

University School of Law

LL.B

Sir. L.A Shah Law College

Other Info

No. of juniors with me

3

Size of my team

7

No. of intern work per year

5

Other Legal Experience

Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority

Empaneled with Organizations

Legal Retainer for many companies with global presence

Corporate Counsel

S.V Raju Associates.

Associate/Partner in a Law firm

GLH

Empaneled with Organizations

Client Testimonials

Top Responding Lawyers

Experience: 33 Year(s)
Retired Judge
Bangalore
Experience: 9 Year(s)
Lawyer and legal associate
Nagpur
Experience: 2 Year(s)
As a advocate
Aurangabad
Experience: 1 Year(s)
Advocate
Kolkata
Experience: 22 Year(s)
Advocate
Bhubaneswar
Experience: 9 Year(s)
Adv.Ambrose Leo Associates & Legal Consultants
Bangalore
Experience: 15 Year(s)
Advocate High Court
Kolkata
Experience: 11 Year(s)
Attorney
South Delhi
Experience: 5 Year(s)
Lawyer
New Delhi
Experience: 19 Year(s)
Advocate
Bangalore
Experience: 15 Year(s)
Advocate
Panipat
Experience: 14 Year(s)
Advocate and Legal Counsel
Kolkata
Experience: 3 Year(s)
Criminal Lawyer
Faridabad
Experience: 20 Year(s)
Dr
New Delhi
Experience: 12 Year(s)
Advocate
Thane
Experience: 38 Year(s)
SENIOR LAWYER
Jabalpur
Experience: 18 Year(s)
Advocate / Trial Advocate
Tirunelveli
Experience: 4 Year(s)
Advocate
Faridabad
Experience: 17 Year(s)
Lawyer,Attorney,Solicitor
Kanpur
Experience: 18 Year(s)
Advocate
Chennai
Experience: 17 Year(s)
Advocate
Patna
Experience: 17 Year(s)
Advocate
Thiruvananthapuram
Experience: 2 Year(s)
Advocate
New Delhi
Experience: 15 Year(s)
Advocate High Court
Allahabad
Experience: 6 Year(s)
Advocate
Ludhiana
Talk to a Lawyer
Post Your Matter
Request Callback
Contact Us