Is it high-time for gender-neutral rape laws?


Posted On : March 2, 2023
Is it high-time for gender-neutral rape laws?
A recent judgement passed by the Allahabad High Court held that while women cannot commit rape, she can be held in aiding the same and hence, the question rises, how badly do we need rape laws to be gender neutral?
Listen to this article

Table of Contents

Introduction


In India, the law that deals with sexual offenses is the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 2013, which was amended after the brutal gang rape of a young woman in Delhi in 2012. The act includes provisions for rape and sexual assault, but it does not have a specific provision for gender-neutral rape.

In other words, as per the current legal framework in India, only men can be charged with rape. However, the definition of rape under the law includes forced sexual intercourse, oral sex, or penetration with any object without the victim's consent, and this can apply to any victim, regardless of gender.

There have been calls for a gender-neutral rape law in India, especially from the LGBTQ+ community, which argues that the current law is discriminatory and leaves many victims without legal recourse. However, as of now, there has been no specific legislation passed to address this issue.

It is important to note that sexual assault and harassment are still underreported and stigmatized in India, and more needs to be done to support survivors and address the underlying social and cultural factors that contribute to such crimes.


The situation now-


India's current rape laws only recognize men as perpetrators and women as victims, which can be seen as discriminatory towards those who don't identify within these traditional gender categories, including transgender individuals, non-binary people, and men who have been sexually assaulted.

The existing rape law in India is gender-specific and considers only men capable of committing rape. The legal definition of rape is "sexual intercourse" between a man and a woman without the woman's consent. This definition, however, does not cover the range of sexual assaults that can happen, such as forced oral sex, anal penetration, or non-consensual sexual contact with any gender.

There have been instances where people who did not identify as female were not able to file a rape case or any sexual assault case because the law did not recognize their experiences. This can make it difficult for such victims to get justice or to even report such incidents to the authorities.

There has been a growing demand from activists and members of the LGBTQ+ community in India for a gender-neutral rape law to be passed. Such a law would recognize all individuals, regardless of gender identity, as potential victims and offenders. The demand for a gender-neutral law has also been supported by the United Nations, which has called on India to amend its laws to ensure that all victims of sexual violence have access to justice.

There have been attempts to introduce gender-neutral rape laws in the Indian Parliament in the past, but they have not been successful in being passed. The issue is complex, and there are concerns about how such a law would be enforced, particularly in cases where the perpetrator and the victim have different gender identities.


Status of gender neutral rape law outside India


Many countries around the world have laws that recognize rape and sexual assault as crimes that can be committed against people of any gender. In recent years, there has been an increasing recognition of the need for gender-neutral rape laws to address the issue of sexual violence against marginalized communities, including transgender people, non-binary individuals, and men who have been sexually assaulted.

In some countries, the law recognizes rape and sexual assault as crimes that can be committed against any person, regardless of gender. For example, in the United Kingdom, the Sexual Offences Act 2003 defines rape as sexual intercourse without the consent of the person and does not specify the gender of the victim or the perpetrator.

Similarly, in Sweden, the law recognizes rape as a crime that can be committed against any person and defines it as sexual intercourse or another sexual act that is carried out against a person's will by means of violence, threat, or coercion.

In some other countries, the law specifically recognizes that men can be victims of rape and sexual assault. For instance, in the United States, many states have laws that recognize rape as a crime that can be committed against any person, regardless of gender. The definition of rape varies across different states, but many states recognize that men can be victims of rape and sexual assault.

However, there are still many countries where the law does not recognize men or non-binary individuals as potential victims of rape or sexual assault. This can make it difficult for these individuals to report sexual violence and seek justice, as the law may not provide them with adequate legal recourse.

Overall, while there is increasing recognition of the need for gender-neutral rape laws, the legal frameworks and definitions of sexual violence vary widely across different countries, and more work is needed to ensure that all victims of sexual violence, regardless of gender, have access to justice.


Recent judgements in India regarding gender neutral rape law


Since September 2021, there have been no major recent judgments in India regarding the gender-neutral rape law. However, there have been some important legal developments and cases that have highlighted the need for a gender-neutral approach to sexual violence in the country.

In 2018, a landmark judgment was passed by the Supreme Court of India in the Navtej Singh Johar case, which decriminalized homosexuality in the country. The judgment recognized the need for equal rights and protection for all individuals, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity.

In 2020, a transgender woman was allegedly raped by a group of men in Kolkata, and the case was registered under the non-gender-neutral rape law. The victim challenged the law's gender-specific definition of rape, and the Calcutta High Court directed the central government to consider amending the law to make it gender-neutral.

Similarly, in 2021, a transgender woman was allegedly gang-raped in Haryana, and the case was registered under the gender-specific rape law. The victim's lawyer argued that the current law does not recognize sexual violence against transgender individuals and called for a gender-neutral approach to the law.

These cases highlight the urgent need for a gender-neutral rape law in India, which would recognize all individuals as potential victims and perpetrators of sexual violence, regardless of their gender identity. The Indian government and lawmakers must take steps to address this issue and ensure that all victims of sexual violence have access to justice, regardless of their gender.


Conclusion-


The lack of a gender-neutral rape law in India is a serious concern, and it is important for the Indian government to take steps to address this issue. Such a law would help ensure that all victims of sexual violence have access to justice, regardless of their gender identity. It is necessary to recognize the diverse experiences of people who do not fit into the traditional gender binary and ensure that they are protected under the law.

The need for a gender-neutral rape law in India is crucial to ensuring that all victims of sexual violence have access to justice and legal recourse, regardless of their gender identity. It is important for the Indian government to take steps to address this issue and ensure that the law is inclusive and provides adequate protection for all individuals.

Written By:
Anik

Anik

Bangalore

Recommended Free Legal Advices
question markFraud in trust 4 Response(s)
1) In the trust banking accounts the funds cannot be transferred to the trustee themselves without the approval of all the other members and on what basis and for what purpose has such a big amount is transfered to the neutral person 2) As it is very necessary for any transaction above rupees 5000 a separate slip has to be maintained for or the approval of the same 3) Though the cheques are pre-Signed in the trust accounts the approval for the same must have to be taken for each and every transaction of the cheque by all the other members of the trust as and when the funds are transferred to somebody savings account does there should be approval of everybody. 4) For the same you can bring this problem sorted out by your CA for the trust committee members themselves are there or you will have to send a legal notice to the members who have transferred the amount & if still then if the problem is not resolved then rather you will have to approach the charity commissioner of the respective state- if the trust is of Mumbai-Maharashtra then the charity commissioner office is at Worli- Mumbai- Maharsahtra If you realize my professional skills, the time & efforts put in by me needs to be truly appreciated, and then Please “CLICK MY LIKES/ THUMBS UP/GIFT” button shown below this reply format & also CLICK/ WRITE a “REVIEW” in 5 star as I have answered your query in detail. Do show me the entire set of documents & I shall be able to guide you more into this matter. Your query is answered in detail. We can help you in getting done the same & Complete Legal Documentation works. Hope this information is useful ADV. ANISH PALKAR (High Court)
question markspouse issue 2 Response(s)
Hi, Since this is a false case of 498A, you can file a suit for defamation and mental cruelty on all the grounds you mentioned above. It can also be taken as a ground for divorce if you desire to seek so. If you like my answer, please give a good review.
question markAnticipatory Bail and Quash in IPC 376 and 315; Rape and abortion 3 Response(s)
You may go 2 High Court but if it failed then you cannot come to sessions court it is better to go to sessions court at first instance the fee and adjournments depends upon profile of the Advocate usually on the ground of consensual sex it will be allowed
question markCo Neighbour Owners issue / Are opp gender allowed if given on rent to bachelors 4 Response(s)
There is no restrictions as per law to give on rent the apartment to professional boys.u must enter agreement before letting the house.as per state rules.and do police verification.No restrictions to opposite gender to enter House during normal hour but with good and legal intentions
question markRe-criminalization of adultery in section 497 1 Response(s)
Dear Client, There were significant changes made to Section 497 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The Supreme Court of India, in its judgment in September 2018, declared Section 497 unconstitutional and struck it down. The court held that the provision was discriminatory as it only punished a man for adultery and not the woman involved. After this judgment, adultery is no longer a criminal offense in India, and the legal perspective has shifted towards personal matters rather than imposing criminal sanctions. The case is not valid if only one party is married; it applies to both married individuals involved in the act. Thankyou