SETTLEMENT NOT REACHED, MOVE TO CONSUMER COURT? SETTLEMENT NOT REACHED, MOVE TO CONSUMER COURT?

5 years ago

We have entered a joint venture agreement with developer in which apart from joint venture agreement where there is 50-50 ratio sharing of total F.A.R, he has given rs.4 lakh as per agreement which is refundable , there is also a profit sharing agreement in which he is supposed to share 33% of profit. He has given another rs.5 lakh and also he has given rs.6 lakh to my elder brother but he is reluctant to give single penny to me and my mother and my elder sister. He also deliberately concealed the profit sharing agreement and didnt part with us.The developer defaulted in completing the project within 2 years as per agreement , now it is more than 3 years yet he has not completed the project . The extra money rs.3 lakh and rs.5 lakh he has given to elder brother he has given had not taken any no objection from all the owners as per agreement. We have claimed the share of profit but he denied.We have launched complaint online in district consumer dispute redressal commission, claiming the profit with interest,he has probably not replied and they have asked both of us to attend their office. On two days no settlement could be reached. They are denying that there is a profit sharing agreement. We do not have copy of the same. I have tried to collect certified copy from register office but failed. We have got circumstantial evidences. Firstly he has given money more than 4 lakh, he is claiming it has been adjusted but no copy or agreement he could not show. We have taken money on voucher where sometimes it is written that jv adjustment, some time advance. Secondly we have call record where he told that agreement is there but he will produce before the judicial body as we have complaint. He refused give plan, visit his office and the building under construction, his accounts where in the joint venture agreement it is written that we are at liberty to inspect the accounts. Thirdly during the mediation proceeding they have taken the signature of my mother that she is not in the complaint and if she does'nt sign , no money will be given exploiting our financial crunch. In the meantime my mother has got hospitalized and we are in dire need of money. Fouthly , in the complaint itself I had mentioned that he is supressing the profit sharing agreement, I had sent letter personally before launching the complaint claiming the document, he didn't responded, I have been following up from 2016 claiming the document he is not responding. The jv agreement was entered into 2015 nov and supposed complete within 2 years but not completed and handed over the building.
In this circumstance, what should be the best course of action? Will we file suit in consumer court or criminal court? does the consumer court will take care of criminal offences on the basis of circumstantial evidence

Kishan Dutt Kalaskar

Responded 5 years ago

View All Answers
A.Dear Sir,
More appropriate remedy is to approach Civil Court.
Helpful
Helpful
Share

Post Your Matter Post Your Matter

Talk to a Lawyer Talk to a Lawyer

Ask a question Ask a question

Vidhi Samaadhaan Vidhi Samaadhaan

Rameshwar Dadhe

Responded 5 years ago

A.U should file complaint against the builder
Helpful
Helpful
Share

Post Your Matter Post Your Matter

Talk to a Lawyer Talk to a Lawyer

Ask a question Ask a question

Vidhi Samaadhaan Vidhi Samaadhaan

Read Related Answers

question iconComplaint on Apartment Maintenance issue
Dear Client, Per sq, ft method is extensively used for the calculation of the maintenance charges for the societies/RWA across the country. This system of calculation is used when the sizes of apartm...
question iconQuestion on Buying 10 years old flat with registration on hold
Dear Client , you can not rent / lease or sell your property until you have received complete possession of the property. you have to complete registration process for the same before getting into re...
question iconREGISTRATION OF Apartment owners association under companies act
Dear sir, It is ordinarily registered under specific act which might have been enacted by your state government otherwise consult the sub registrar office.
question iconI am being asked to pay more than my neighbour for Open Car Parking
Dear Client, Firstly, document all your interactions with the builder, including dates, times, and any communication (emails, letters, etc.). This documentation will be crucial if you need to escala...
question iconExtra amount for completion of project
Dear Client, Please consult an accountant for the how to include new additional income and if the can be given the rights of a builder. additionally with the consent of the new person they can be a...