Grounds for refusal of a Trademark application


Posted On : May 23, 2022
Grounds for refusal of a Trademark application
Listen to this article

Table of Contents


Intellectual property rights provide for the rights to the owners of intellectual properties to preserve their ownership and to sustain and receive the benefits of their creativity and genius. Trademark is one of the most prominent intellectual property rights. A trademark is a tool that helps a company distinguish itself from other brands to beat the competition. A brand is not necessarily a trademark, but a trademark is always a brand. A trademark is a name, word, or symbol that distinguishes goods from those of other businesses. Marketing goods or services by procedure becomes considerably easier with a trademark because product recognition is secured and made easy. The owner can prevent a competitor from using his mark or symbol.


Trademark Law in India

An Indian Trademark Law was enforced in the 1940s. This law was enforced because of the continuous infringement of the registered and non-registered trademarks. As trade and commerce grew rapidly after the trademark legislation was implemented, demand for trademark protection skyrocketed. The Trademark and Merchandise Act, 1958 replaced the old Trademark law. It provided better protection of trademarks and prevented misuse or fraudulent use of marks on merchandise. This act as well was replaced with the Trademark Act, 1999, by the government of India following the TRIPS (Trade-related Aspectsof Intellectual Property Rights) obligation imposed by the World Trade Organization. The Trademark Act's goal is to protect trademark users by directing property conditions and providing legal remedies for trademark rights enforcement.

Trademark identifies the owner of the product. Trademark piracy is defined as the use of a trademark for commercial gain through unauthorised or illegal means. If a registered trademark is infringed, the owner of the registered trademark can file a case, whereas an unregistered trademark's only alternative is passing off. Anyone claiming to be the owner of a trademark or claiming to have to use it in the future may submit an application in writing to the competent registrar in an authorised manner. The application must include the name of the goods, mark, and services, the class of goods and services in which it falls, the applicant's name and address, and the mark's term of use. A person here refers to a group of firms, a partnership firm, a corporation, a trust, a state government, or the federal government.

 

Grounds for Refusal of a Trademark

Section 9 of the Act defines the absolute grounds for the refusal of registration of the trademark. Trademarks that are devoid of distinguishing qualities or consist solely of marks or signals that might be used in commerce to represent the kind, fine, quantity, alleged grounds, values, or geographical origin, may be rejected. Acreation of time of things or the rendering of offers, or various features of goods or offerings, consisting entirely of signs or signals that have become common in today's language. That trademark is not eligible for registration. Unless it is proven that the mark has acquired a new character as a result of use before the application date. It further provides that a mark shall not be registered as a trademark if:

1.     It deceives or confuses the people.

2.     There is something that can harm religious sensitivity.

3.     It is indecent or scandalous in nature

4.     Its use is forbidden. It states that a trademark cannot be registered if it only contains (a) the shape of products that form the nature of goods, (b) the shape of goods that are required to achieve a technical result, or (c) the shape of goods that gives substantial value to goods.

5.     It is prohibited under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act. 1950.


Test of Similarity

If two marks appear to be deceptively similar, the key qualities of both must be considered. They should not be placed side by side to see if there are any design discrepancies and if they have the same personality to avoid one design being mistaken for the other. It would be sufficient if the challenged mark is so similar to the registered mark that a person who normally deals with one would accept the other if presented to him. Apart from structural, visual, and phonetic similarity or dissimilarity, the question must also be considered in terms of human intelligence and incomplete collecting. The question of his impressions is viewed as an entire third.

"It is general knowledge that 'bidis' are utilised by those belonging to the impoverished and uneducated or semi-literate class," the court said in Mohd. Iqbal v. Mohd. Wasim. Their level of expertise is limited. It is unrealistic to expect children to comprehend and comprehend the subtle differences between the two labels that can be found by comparing the two labels. Given the foregoing, the two labels appear to have a misleading resemblance."

The Act's Section 11 lays forth the relative grounds for a trademark's refusal to be registered. A trademark cannot be registered if there is a likelihood of confusion due to (I) its identity with an earlier brand and resemblance of goods or services, or (II) its similarity to an earlier trademark and similarity of goods. It also states that a trademark that is identical or similar to an earlier brand cannot be registered. Also, if, or to the extent, the earlier trademark is well recognised in India, it must be registered for goods and services that are not identical to those for which an earlier trademark is registered in the name of a different proprietor. It further states that a trademark cannot be registered if or to the extent that its use in India is likely to be prohibited by law.


Conclusion

Intellectual property rights are a new yet booming field of law in today’s time. Trademark is one of the most essential intellectual property rights for a business. It is essential to build their brand, their brand value and their image in the market. People need to know the grounds on which a trademark can be refused. In order to make sure that such grounds for non-refusal are satisfied, which makes it faster for the business to set up and commence their business and function as an independent brand in the market.

 

*****

Written By:
Kishan Dutt Kalaskar Retired Judge

Recommended Free Legal Advices
question markcorporate company contract breach 5 Response(s)
In my opinion everything is based on the agreement if any, and without detail discussion proper consult is not possible.
question markFIR filed against 376,354a,354,452,323,509,506,427 2 Response(s)
Dear Madam, You may go to the office Higher Police Officers or to the Press and see that guy is arrested immediately and he wish to cheat you.
question markIs refusal to accept time-barred notices/summons legally valid or not? 3 Response(s)
Sir, even though you have not taken the summons. The police has come to your place and have told you about a case which has been filed against you. You are aware of such case and have not taken the summons as they were time barred. It should not be a problem as there should be a delivery of another summon asking you to be present in the court on such next date fixed for your appearance. However to be on the safe side it is requested that you consult a lawyer and keep a track of the proceedings of such case lodged against you and make sure that just due to non appearance, the court does not issue a warrant against you because of which you will ultimately need to be present in the court and seek bail. Thanks
question markBan of Housemaid on the basis of refusal to work 3 Response(s)
The answer to your questions depends on what kind of rules and byelaws the RWA has made wherein you have also given your consent for the same for some specific matters and housemaid could be one of them. In general RWA cannot bar the movement of (all) people who are allowed to come in by the residents. Some specific set of people like hawkers, maids, vendors might be but there has to be a rule for that agreed by all.
question markConfusion over trademark requirement 4 Response(s)
You can start selling on Amazon even without a trademark but the question is that no body will be able to recognize your products and their value proposition. So, better suggested that you get a trademark for your company or product and then start selling.
Expert Lawyers in Intellectual Property, Copyright, Patent, Trademark