Startups are often stuck over LLP vs Pvt. Ltd. when it comes to giving a separate identity to their business. There are various similarities like both Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) and a Private Limited Company are separate entities in the eyes of law, separate from the members running them. Even the liability of designated partners in LLP is limited just like the directors or shareholders in a Pvt. Ltd. company. Then what is the difference between an LLP and Pvt. Ltd. company? What are the pros and cons of LLP vs Pvt. Ltd.? And then ultimately, LLP vs Pvt. Ltd. - Which is better for a startup business? All such doubts have been addressed till the end of this page.
In the business world, it is a crucial task to give an identity to the same. A company is a renowned term which is governed by the Companies Act, 2013 in India. Section 2 (20) of the Act defines a company as the one incorporated under the same Act. Basically, there are certain legal formalities for incorporation of a company with the Registrar of the Companies which is overlooked by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. A private limited company is the one with limited liability which can be incorporated by two or more members. In case of any losses in business carried out by a Pvt. Ltd. Company, the directors or shareholders are liable to the extent of their shares or interests in the company. They do not need to sell off their private assets in order to discharge the liability of the company.
A partnership is governed by the Partnership Act, 1932. It provides rules and regulations for a partnership firm in India. It can be understood as two or more partners coming together to run a business but share the whole liability for any losses incurred. In case of business loss beyond the assets held by partnership firms, the partners will have to discharge the same through their own private assets.
To evade such a situation while still keeping the identity of a partnership shielded as a separate entity, the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 came into force. It can be said as a look alike of both partnership firms and a Pvt. Ltd. company. An LLP also enjoys corporate features like limited liability, separate entity, perpetual succession, etc. The LLP vs Pvt. Ltd. advantages and disadvantages are quite similar but eventually different as well.
Basis |
LLP |
Pvt Ltd |
Governing Statute |
Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 |
Companies Act, 2013 |
Governing Body |
Ministry of Corporate Affairs |
Ministry of Corporate Affairs |
Identity |
Partnership |
Company |
Minimum Capital |
No |
No |
Governing Document |
Partnership Deed/ Agreement |
Memorandum of Association (MoA) and Article of Association (AoA) |
Name Requisites |
LLP at the end of name |
Pvt. Ltd. at the end of name |
Liability |
Limited liability |
Liability limited to no. of shares held by members |
Members |
Min - 2 designated partners Max - No limit |
Directors - 2 to 15 Members 2 to 200 |
Members and Owners |
Partners are owners of LLP and manage the business |
Directors are the Managers of Business while Shareholders are the owners |
Investors |
Only partners can invest into business. (Angel investors or other ventures are rare) |
Can seek investment by giving shareholding in the company |
Audits |
Not required immediately. Audit is not mandatory unless partners contribution exceeds 25 lakhs and annual turnover exceeds 40 lakhs |
Auditor has to be appointed within 30 days, form filled within 45 days and audit has to be conducted on annual basis |
Meetings |
No legal requirement |
Provisions for Annual General Meeting (AGM) and Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) |
Compliance |
Comparatively less compliance requirements |
A lot of compliance work |
Annual Filing |
Form 8 and Form 11 |
AOC 4 and MGT7 |
Although the LLP vs Pvt. Ltd advantages and disadvantages may vary for people and businesses, some pros of an LLP over the other have been pointed below:
To explore LLP vs Pvt. Ltd. company, which is better among the two, a Private Limited Company is a more recognized and reliable entity among the general public as compared to an LLP. Even for international business purposes, a Pvt Ltd. company is more preferred over the LLP. The difference between Pvt Ltd and LLP also does not allow startup LLP to raise funds from outsiders who are not partners. In case of wishful business partners who plan to escape any liability in business after a certain limit, LLP is always a better option. In other words, LLP often suffers from lack of credibility as compared to a Pvt. Ltd. company. More clarity on the concept can be sought through corporate law firms in Kolkata or the local firms in the said location of the proposed business partners.
In case the members of the business are planning to seek investments from venture capitalists or other investors and wondering ‘LLP vs Pvt. Ltd. company, which is better?’, the answer lies with a Pvt. Ltd. It is also considered a more recognized and reliable form of business organization among the people. If there are any further doubts over LLP vs Pvt. Ltd company, consultation with a corporations lawyer may be of great help.
Yes, people planning for business startups are legally enabled to first register as a Limited Liability Partnership and later on get the same registered as a Private Limited Company. Since the difference between Pvt. Ltd. and LLP has been explained above, one can understand the pretext of what is the need of the hour. But since there is no universal delineation when it comes to pros and cons of LLP vs Pvt. Ltd., registering as a Private Ltd. company should be no harm.