Track Your Request
Track Your Request
+91-7604047602 Our Team About Us Legal Blog Free Legal Advice Login
Menu
Vidhikarya Text Logo
arrow_back

MARRIAGE HALL CONTRACTS – LEGAL STATUS OF BOTH PARTIES IN THE LIGHT OF COVID-19


Many marriages are postponed owing to the pandemic. But, the marriage halls, booked well in advance, seldom refund the advance amount paid. There are constraints for both the marriage halls, as well as the person who has paid the advance. This article delves into the legal status of the parties.;

It is quite true that the COVID 19 pandemic has devastated the normal pace of life. There have been many businesses which were affected, and one such business contract which have been commonly entered into by many persons is the booking of marriage halls.

Marriages are conducted in great pomp and splendour in India. The general Indian notion is that a marriage is a once-in-a-lifetime event and worth spending a lot of money. Marriage halls are booked well in advance, and in most cases, the rent for the marriage halls is paid much early, even six months before the marriage. Such contracts for the letting out of the marriage halls get frustrated because of the Government imposed regulations of the conduct of such functions.

One of the main objects of law is to prevent unjust enrichment. When the marriage halls are paid for, but cannot be used by the contractee, it is an uncalled suffering. The culpability is heaped on the outbreak of the pandemic. But, many marriage halls are reluctant to refund the rent paid.[1] Their general contention is that there was no frustration caused by the marriage halls, and there has been equal impact on their business due to the pandemic.

Let us delve into the legal position. An agreement to do an impossible act is declared void under sec. 56 of the Indian Contract Act. More importantly, an agreement to do an act which has become impossible after the contract is made, due to some event which the promisor could not prevent, becomes void. The contract is valid on the inception, but it becomes void due to the reason, the agreement cannot be performed.

Reference must be made an old English case Taylor v. Caldwell [2]. In this case, agreement was in relation to the let out of a music hall on certain dates. However, the said music hall caught fire before the first date of the concert, due to fault of neither parties. The plaintiff sued the defendant for the losses. The Bench opined that the contract was not absolute, and subject to an implied condition that the parties shall be excused in case, before breach, the contract becomes impossible without the performance of the contractor.

Now, there is a clash of two contentions. The contractees claim the principle of absolute liability in relation to the sanctity of the contract. The contractors raise take shelter of the principle that the shared contractual assumption that has been destroyed under the circumstances. The court will take into consideration as to whether any untoward event supervenes the performance of the contract.

Beyond all these, it must be remembered that law is dependant on social dynamics. These legal principles may not alter the general mindset of the parties. The return of the amount is inevitable, but a recovery suit for the same is unthinkable, given the general prevalence of a notion that civil suits take a long time to get adjudicated. The marriage halls are in a dominant position and the contractees are in a subservient position, owing to the fact that the payment has been made already.

Nevertheless, all the above circumstances are based on contracts read in isolation. If a marriage hall refuses to refund the advance paid, the said refusal must subsist for a number of such contracts, considering the fact the pandemic has been in existence for months together. So, when he is put to defend a number of lawsuits together, it would be catastrophic for him, if not placing him in a situation of formulating a common method of settlement. If he does not treat the contractees with parity, he is put to greater civil liability under the common law remedy for his ulterior discrimination. Thus, there is no incidence of unjust enrichment. It would on the whole be advisable for the marriage halls to work out a win-win settlement mechanism to solve any such future disputes.

This is one understanding of how the object of law is upheld at all times by social action. The victims who impose faith in the remedy and recourse available are never left unprotected. 



Posted On : July 18, 2020

Written By :
Viswanath M K
Viswanath M K
Chennai |

Recommended Free Legal Advices
question markServing notice period
If you are ready to pay salary in lieu of the notice period then send them a formal mail/letter for the same and even after that if the HR is not agreeing then you quit by depositing all the assets to the company. Later if the company is making ant legal issues out of that then you can show them the mail/letter.
question markNotice period payment
Generally, companies have a clause of notice period wherein employee must work for the notice period and Full and Final settlement is made after notice period is served. Case-1 (Notice period clause present) If your company has notice period clause in employment agreement (on stamp paper) or appointment letter, and you left immediately after resignation, then they can deduct the notice period pay. Case-2 (Notice Period Clause not present) If there is no such notice period clause, then by law employer cannot deduct any pay from you and your last working day shall be considered as date of leaving for purpose of paying full and final. The constitution of India provides the fundamental right to every person to choose the profession of his choice and any agreement contrary to this is invalid. By putting the clause in service regulation that it is company’s discretion to accept the notice or not is against the provisions of constitution of India. Hence company cannot threaten you by showing this clause. The Company cannot force you to serve the entire notice period. I want to clarify that Bond period is a different concept which is different from Notice period. Bond period makes you bound to work for certain time (usually 1 year). Bond period is illegal but notice period is legal if agreed under employment letter/ agreement etc. Hope it clarifies. I can suggest more only by reading the documents. You may approach me through Vidhikarya for further clarifications.
question markdata entry fraud
Dear Sir, You need not pay any amount and ask them to approach any Court to recover the same. I could have explained more if background is known to me. I am at your service if you visit my office. Please give me FIVE STAR if satisfied by my answers and you may approach me through Vidhikarya for further clarifications.
question markRegarding Lease Deed/ Agreement
Dear Sir, You may approach any local chartered accountant to get effective legal advise relating to finance and tax matters. I could have explained more if background is known to me. I am at your service if you visit my office. Please give me FIVE STAR if satisfied by my answers and you may approach me through Vidhikarya for further clarifications.
question markLegal advice on Building contractor
It is necessary to scrutinize the Contract papers entered by and between parties as well as the document through which you had terminated such contract specifying the grounds of such termination as well as the reply of that contractor in this regard. To give opinion, relevant documentary evidences are to be scrutinized as a whole.

Please enter the text

Categories

Civil(43)
Family(40)
News(2)
Others(14)
RTI(7)
Sale(5)
Tax(4)
Torts(4)
Will(4)
Writ(1)

Send your queries to

[email protected]
X
Consult Landlord and Tenant Lawyers from your City!
Post Your Matter
Post Your Matter to connect with the Lawyer online
Call 7604047602 for any assistance
Our Team
Lawyer Login
Be a Partner
Internship
Career

Download the Lawyers App on

Vidhikarya App on Android Platform
Contact Details
7604047602
[email protected]
No. 2, First Floor, Subharaj
Plot No. CE/1/C/19, Premises No. 18-0208,
Action Area- 1, New Town
Kolkata-700156