Loophole in Petitioner's response to the counter and counter claim Loophole in Petitioner's response to the counter and counter claim

10 months ago

The respondent affirms that the petitioner is physically impotent and could not consummate the marriage, but this could not be proven because the petitioner had submitted 2 certificates in the contrary. The respondent was also tortured mentally by the petitioner therefore the divorce is on the grounds of cruelty under section 13(1)(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act. The petitioner however wants to join back with the respondent in matrimonial life.

Now in the recent response to the counter and counter claim, the respondent found a loophole in paragraph 22 which is as follows:

"22. I deny the allegations and averments contained in para 16 of the counter and counter claim filed by the respondent as false and vexatious. Only on the love and affection towards the
respondent, I have requested to come to matrimonial house and I never feared about the disclosure of non consummation of our marriage. I never threatened the respondent that if the respondent
disclosed about the non consummation of our marriage to her parents, I would commit suicide."

In this statement " I never feared about the disclosure of non consummation of our marriage" the petitioner is agreeing that their marriage was non consummate which is contradicting to the earlier claim that the petitioner made of not being physically impotent. My question is can we use this in the court or not since the divorce request by the respondent is on the grounds of cruelty? Can this loophole be beneficial for the respondent in brining forward the truth about the physical impotence of the petitioner again?

Anik

Responded 10 months ago

View All Answers
A.Dear client,

It can be used in the court in a manner beneficial to the respondent, but the case cannot be won solely based on this alone; there needs to be other evidence to support the respondent's case as well.
Helpful
Helpful
Share

Post Your Matter Post Your Matter

Talk to a Lawyer Talk to a Lawyer

Ask a question Ask a question

Vidhi Samaadhaan Vidhi Samaadhaan

Read Related Answers

question iconHusband harrasment
Dear Client, In the prevailing situation, you have the right to file a complaint against your unruly husband who subjected you to mental and emotional abuse that amounted to domestic violence in the...
question iconMental harassment by husband staying in Pune on wife living in Bangalore
Dear Madam, Please file multiple cases against your husband and his family members. You can get maintenance easily thus he may come for compromise.
question iconSexless Marriage
Dear Client, If the mental agony arising out of ill-treatment or misbehavior of your unruly and errant wife has now reached an extreme level having no scope of reunion despite possible efforts, you ma...
question iconMy wife wants divorce suddenly stating the reason that she doesn’t like my behaviour after 11 years
Dear Client, Your query requires more details to address it suitably. You expressed your situation but not a cause of action that attracts a legal remedy. It is a virtual platform where in the absence...
question iconMy husband use to beat me badly
Dear Client, Cruelty is a ground for divorce in India for all the religious laws. It may be physical as well as mental cruelty. So, you can file a case for being a victim of domestic violence. Accordi...