This is regarding the dispute against a  real estate builder. This is regarding the dispute against a real estate builder.

6 months ago

We booked an apartment in Chennai with a reputed builder (XYZ construction company), My husband is an NRI and during his vacation when we were searching for a property in our preferred location, we found the one which we felt suitable for the intended and visited the site and found it reasonable.
We opted for a home loan and requested the builder to complete all the necessary process within 10 to 15 days as my husband was in India for short duration only and they agreed. We paid 10% of the property value as booking advance 4,93,448/- (Four lakh ninety-three thousand four hundred and forty-eight rupees) as per the demand raised by the sales team to get agreement copy and documents for verification and legal purpose.
Initial quoted price of the Property was 49,34,483/- and after some discount the revised property value was 49,07,855/-.
Paid token advance 1,00,000/- (One Lakh rupees only) on 5th April 2023 and remaining amount of 3,93,448/- (Three lakh ninety-three thousand four forty-eight) on 18th April 2023.
Home loan process eligibility has been checked and the principle approval letter was issued on 26th April 2023. But the builder failed to submit the agreement on time due to demises of land owner (which we got to know very late after several calls ) and the complete process was delayed. Even after many follow ups there was no proper response. They couldn’t turn up with valid reason for delay in getting agreement prepared. For few days no calls had been answered and we lost the trust and sent an email requesting refund on 22nd May 2023. Still no reply or call from them.
My husband left India on 1st June 2023. On 6th June 2023 we got reply from CRM stating that the office people were on annual leave from mid may 2023 till 5th June 2023 and that’s why couldn’t answer the calls and respond to mail on time. But the subject cancellation request was completely ignored.
On 20th June finally got mail regarding the issues with the property is resolved and agreements were ready for signing and demanding for the remaining stage payment due till that date which was close to 28 lakhs. We did not respond to it, still communication with CRM going on through phone for refund.
On 29th July 2023 we were shocked to see mail from CRM heading “Unit open for sale” and cancellation charges + Late fee charges + GST all together 5,69,450/- and refund amount “0”.
After many follow ups and escalation within the organisation, they finally agreed to refund 3,81,958/- after deducting sum of 1,11,490/- (which is 20% of payment made + GST) Which we refuse to agree. When we asked for the explanation, they claimed it was given in the terms while signing booking form.

I request the valuable members in guiding us how to proceed in getting the full amount refund without any deduction.
What are the rights you we have , to proceed legally against the builder?

Points to remember:
We haven’t signed any agreement until now.
Most of the initial communication happened through phone and we have no email evidence.
Until now sales person stands with us and he accepted they failed to full fill what was promised, he helped us escalating the matter to reasonable level but refund team is threatening him and boycott in this issue.
As of now , they claim we signed the booking form and terms have been already mentioned.

Legal Counsel Vidhikarya

Responded 6 months ago

View All Answers
A.Dear Client,
If the apartment you booked in Chennai is an approved project of RERA, then as per Sec.13(1) of the Real Estate(R & D) Act, 2016, the Builder/Developer cannot take a sum as advance/booking money of more than 10% of the consideration value of the flat from the Buyer without entering into the Agreement for sale with the prospective buyer and even after receipt of booking money, delay in execution of Agreement proves the deficiency in service and unfair trade practice on the part of Developer. In this context, a point with regard to the sanction of a Bank loan requires clarification, i.e, how the Bank issues a provisional sanction of a loan in favor of a buyer in the absence of an Agreement to sale and other documents like approved building plans, Joint Development Agreement with the owner of the land and POA in favour of Developer etc. In the absence of an Agreement to Sale executed between the Developer and the Buyer/Purchaser, if the booking money or advance is remitted to the Developer either online or through cheque, then based on that document, after serving a legal notice to the Developer, you may escalate your complaint against the Developer either before the RERA, even the project is not approved by them or before the Dist. Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission under Sec.35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 over alleged deficiency in service and unfair trade practice claiming refund of entire booking money with interest along with compensation for harassment and cost of litigation. Get in touch with an Advocate with experience in real estate matters for guidance and steps. If you need any legal assistance from us in this regard, you may contact our legal team with all your relevant papers.
Helpful
Helpful
Share

Post Your Matter Post Your Matter

Talk to a Lawyer Talk to a Lawyer

Ask a question Ask a question

Vidhi Samaadhaan Vidhi Samaadhaan

Anik

Responded 6 months ago

View All Answers
A.Dear
Carefully review the terms and conditions mentioned in the booking form and If the builder is not cooperating with your request for a full refund, consider sending a legal notice and If the issue remains unresolved, you may need to consider filing a formal complaint with the appropriate consumer protection authorities or real estate regulatory authorities in Chennai.
Helpful
Helpful
Share

Post Your Matter Post Your Matter

Talk to a Lawyer Talk to a Lawyer

Ask a question Ask a question

Vidhi Samaadhaan Vidhi Samaadhaan

Read Related Answers

question iconRegularization
Dear sir, You may contact local advocate who is well known with local laws especially the building laws of your area to solve your problem.
question iconRegarding Bank account details mentioned in Sales Agreement
Dear Client, Usually, the contents of a Sale Agreement made by the Builders remain pro-builder guarding the interest of the Builder. But as a party to the said agreement you have the right to amend an...
question iconHouse registry in Haryana
Dear Client, In the absence of the original Seller and the original Buyer, a rectification deed or supplementary deed to rectify the error in the Schedule of Property of the original deed cannot be ma...
question iconLTCG ON SALE OF PROPERTY
Dear sir, Section 8 of Hindu Succession Act: ==================================================================== General rules of succession in the case of males.―The property of a male Hindu dyin...
question iconRelinquishment deed signing by sister
Dear sir, Yes if your wife signs relinquishment deed then she will loose her share. The other party can sell the entire property. Stamp duty etc. depends upon state government rule please check sub re...